Eight questions to ask before handing your building to an agency
A pitch meeting usually covers experience and the size of the portfolio. Those are the two things easiest to check elsewhere. The eight questions below are about what rarely appears in a brochure, and what you will live with for years.
The short version
Ask them in writing and ask for the answers in writing. That is not suspicion: it is what lets you compare two proposals three weeks later, and what pins down what was promised. Three of these questions rest directly on the law: accounts (art. 400 CO), termination (art. 404 CO) and the rental deposit (art. 257e CO).
1. What exactly does your percentage cover?
USPI Genève, the trade association, publishes the list of what an ordinary mandate covers: collection and charges, leases and tenants, maintenance of the building. Anything outside that list is billed on top.
Ask for the list item by item, and above all for what is not on it.
2. How are works remunerated?
This is the most important of the eight, because it is about a conflict of interest: when fees are a percentage of the amount spent, the person advising you on the scope of a job earns more if you spend more. We set this out in detail in our guide on what a property management mandate covers.
With us, routine maintenance is at 0%: a repair earns us nothing. Larger works carry a reduced fee, set in the contract.
Ask for the rate, what it is calculated on, the threshold at which it applies and any cap.
3. Who holds the money, and in which account?
For the rental deposit the law leaves no choice: it goes into a bank account in the tenant's name, three months' rent at most for a home (art. 257e CO).
For the rest there are three models, and we run all three:
- You keep control of everything. The accounts are yours; we have read access.
- The accounts are separate. You run the rent account, we run the day-to-day expenses account.
- We run both on your behalf.
Any serious agency should offer you all three. If only one is on the table, ask why.
4. How often, and in what form, do you account to me?
Article 400 CO gives you the right to demand accounts at any time, whatever frequency the contract sets.
But the right answer is not a frequency. It is permanent access: figures kept current, every invoice viewable, every entry traceable back to its voucher. A quarterly statement is a summary you have to take on trust. Full access is a set of accounts you can check yourself, on the day you need to.
5. Do you receive money from third parties in connection with my building?
Article 400 CO also requires the agency to hand over everything it has received in that capacity, on whatever basis. Supplier rebates, insurance commissions, retrocessions: the question is legitimate, and it belongs before signature rather than after.
A yes or a no will do. If it is yes, ask how those amounts reach you or are credited against your account.
6. How quickly do you answer a tenant?
Your tenants are your customers. The rent comes from them, and their experience decides whether they stay. An unanswered request becomes a chaser, then a heavier repair, then a departure. Every one of those steps costs you money.
With us, a tenant gets an answer at any hour, in their own language, through whatever channel they already use: message, email or phone. That is where the trade is going, and it is the easiest thing to test before you sign: write to the agency you are considering, on an evening or a weekend, and see what happens.
7. How long do you take to re-let?
The canton's vacancy rate is 0.31%, the lowest since 2011: 793 empty homes in the whole of Geneva. A home put on the market properly should not stay empty for long.
On a three-room flat at CHF 2'400, one month empty costs CHF 2'400, or 8.3% of the year's income. Ask for an average actually recorded, not a target.
8. What happens when the mandate ends?
Article 404 CO allows a mandate to be revoked at any time, whatever term is announced. What is negotiated is therefore not the right to leave, but what happens next.
Have them cover the notice period, the final statement, the list of documents returned and how long it takes to get them.
And one thing you cannot ask
A well-negotiated contract is no substitute for trust. What you are really looking for is not only a rate: it is not having to think about it, knowing someone is looking after your building properly.
That does not show up in a proposal. It shows in the conversation: whether you get precise answers, whether they say no when the answer is no, whether they explain things you did not think to ask. Keep looking until that is the case. It is the one question here whose answer is never written down.
Frequently asked questions
Can fees be negotiated?
Ask directly. What is usually negotiable is not the headline rate but the scope: what the percentage includes, and what falls outside it.
What if an agency will not answer in writing?
That is an answer in itself. Article 400 CO gives you a right to accounts once the mandate is signed, but an agency that will not set out its fees before signature will not set them out afterwards either.
If you are comparing proposals, our property management page sets out what the mandate covers, and our Geneva page explains how we work on the ground.
